A person holding their credit card in front of their laptop screen showing a sale online - MAP Policies and Holiday Sales: The Discount Dilemma

MAP Policies and Holiday Sales: The Discount Dilemma

Major sales events like Mother's Day, Independence Day, Memorial Day, Black Friday, Cyber Monday, and Christmas can make or break an online retailer’s profitability. 

With how critical these holidays are, brands are faced with a conundrum: should they allow their resellers to violate MAP during these sales extravaganzas, or should they uphold their MAP policies without exception? “MAP holidays” can be a useful tool in a brand’s toolbelt, but brands must tread carefully when allowing resellers to break MAP.  

In this article, we'll guide you through the decision-making process and provide the essential blueprint for implementation. 

 

Part 1: Should You Use a MAP Holiday?

The holiday season presents both tremendous opportunity and high risk for brand integrity. This section provides an authoritative breakdown of the benefits and potential dangers of suspending your Minimum Advertised Price (MAP) policy. By weighing the pros and cons of a temporary price reduction, you can confidently determine if a MAP holiday aligns with your long-term pricing strategy and business goals.

 

The Case for MAP Holidays

During major sales events, consumers are more likely to make impulse purchases due to the perceived urgency and exclusivity of the deals. Allowing resellers to violate MAP during these time frames could lead to a significant increase in sales, which may be beneficial for both the brand and its resellers.

By implementing MAP holidays, brands can give their resellers the opportunity to capture a larger share of the market, which could translate to higher profits for all parties involved.

This can strengthen the relationships between resellers and brands, leading to better MAP compliance throughout the rest of the year. By granting temporary MAP waivers during these predetermined periods, brands can prevent unauthorized MAP violations from occurring at other times, ensuring that their pricing strategies remain consistent and competitive in the long run.
 

While holiday sales can be a boon for retailers, it is crucial to maintain brand integrity and pricing consistency

 

The Case Against MAP Holidays

On the other hand, allowing resellers to violate MAP policies, even on a temporary basis, can have several negative consequences. If brands choose to allow MAP holidays, they must tread carefully to mitigate these potential pitfalls.

First and foremost, allowing resellers to sell below MAP can undermine the brand's perceived value in the eyes of consumers. After all, that’s the point of MAP in the first place. Consistent pricing is essential to maintaining a brand's image and reputation, and frequent fluctuations in pricing can lead to a perception that the brand's products are of lower quality or less valuable than they actually are.

If brands choose to allow MAP holidays, they must do it for short, predictable timeframes. In other words, a limited-time price decrease around Black Friday is less likely to damage a brand’s value than price decreases throughout the year that aren’t tied to any specific date.

Brands must also be careful when granting MAP waivers, and they must do it fairly. Resellers who have access to exclusive MAP holidays may be able to outprice their competitors, leading to an uneven playing field and potentially driving smaller resellers out of business. This can ultimately result in a loss of valuable retail partnerships and reduced diversity in the brand's distribution network.

Another concern is the old slippery slope. Implementing MAP holidays may encourage resellers to push for additional exceptions or leniency in other aspects of their agreements with the brand. This can weaken the brand's overall bargaining power and make it more difficult to enforce other important aspects of their business relationships, such as marketing guidelines or product exclusivity agreements. If you give an inch, don’t let them take a mile.
 

Evaluating the Decision

Ultimately, the decision to allow resellers to violate MAP during major sales events like Black Friday and Cyber Monday is not a simple yes or no. It requires a nuanced evaluation of the potential benefits and drawbacks against your brand’s long-term value.

If a brand is considering implementing MAP holidays, it should:
 
  • Weigh Potential Impact: Carefully weigh the potential for increased sales against the potential damage to its brand image and the competitive landscape.
  • Alternative Strategies: Before deciding on a MAP holiday, consider alternative strategies to support your resellers during major sales events without violating MAP policies. These could include offering special promotions, bundling products, or providing additional marketing support to help resellers stand out from the competition.
  • Compliance Awareness: Ensure internal and external compliance officers are aware of any sanctioned MAP holidays. Systems like MAPP Trap’s automated Policy Enforcer allow brands to set blackout dates to correspond with MAP holidays. This way, mistaken accusations don’t happen, and no accidental friction is created.

The core of a successful strategy is finding the balance: balancing the needs of your resellers with your long-term business objectives.
 

Mapp_trap_holiday_poem-(2).jpg

Part 2: How to Implement a MAP Holiday Correctly

If a brand decides a MAP holiday supports its growth strategy, the next step is making sure the plan is carried out smoothly. A temporary change in policy needs clear structure, steady communication, and careful oversight. This section walks through the practical steps that help you organize the promotion, keep expectations aligned, and maintain the strength of your pricing standards from start to finish.


1. Defining Your MAP Holiday Framework

Your policy must explicitly define the terms of promotional flexibility. Brands typically choose one of two models, with clear parameters defined in advance:
 
  • Brand-Declared Holidays (Recommended): The brand announces specific promotional periods with defined start and end dates (e.g., Black Friday through Cyber Monday). This is generally preferred as it maintains maximum control over pricing windows.
  • Retailer-Elected Holidays (Use with Caution): Authorized sellers choose their holiday periods within brand-set parameters (e.g., "resellers may select three days in Q4 for MAP waivers"). This allows flexibility but makes monitoring more complex.

You must also be specific about the nature of the price adjustment:
 
  • Flexing the MAP Floor: Instead of removing MAP, you can temporarily increase the discount percentage, moving the MAP price from, for example, 10% below MSRP to 30% below MSRP for the specified duration.
  • Category and Geographic Variation: Recognize that MAP holidays may need to be tailored by product category or geography (e.g., an apparel brand may run monthly holidays, while a tech brand focuses only on Cyber Monday).


2. Addressing Common Brand Challenges & Loopholes

The rise of e-commerce and major sales events makes it difficult to control pricing and distribution. By focusing on extensive monitoring and proactive policy updates, brands can protect their channels:
 
  • Combatting Unauthorized Resellers & Arbitrage: Gray market or unauthorized sellers undercut official resellers, damaging reputation. Combat this issue by employing advanced monitoring tools to identify these sellers, taking legal action, and working closely with authorized resellers to combat retail arbitrage activity.
  • Closing Hidden Discounts & Pricing Loopholes: Monitoring must address violations that occur outside the advertised price. Ensure your monitoring tools track in-cart pricing and coupon code applications. Close policy loopholes for tactics like Buy One Get One (BOGO) Offers and "Click/Add-to-Cart for Price" by explicitly stating that the advertised price applies to any visible indication of a price before checkout.
  • Maintaining Brand Value (DTC): Strengthen your Direct-to-Consumer (DTC) channels to maintain control over pricing and customer experience. Regularly monitor online marketplaces to identify price violations.
 

3. Building Strategic Relationships (The Enforcement Model)

 

Maintaining positive relationships with resellers while enforcing MAP is a delicate balance. You must enforce the policy consistently and with a strategy that is aimed at maintaining an amicable relationship.
 
  • Advance Notice: Provide adequate advance notice (weeks, not days) to authorized sellers about the terms, duration, and specific products included in the MAP holiday.
  • Fair and Consistent Enforcement: Maintain a firm but flexible approach to enforcement. Avoid overwhelming top-compliant sellers with automated emails for minor infractions.
  • The Carrot-and-Stick Model: 3Enforcement must be customized based on reseller history. Handle a minor pricing issue by a top reseller differently than repeated, multi-SKU violations. Incentivize compliance by offering rewards, trade promotion dollars, or early inventory access to those who comply.
 

Breeze Through MAP Holiday Sales with Us

Are you struggling to decide whether to implement MAP holidays or seek guidance on enforcing your MAP policy? MAPP Trap can help! Our comprehensive suite of tools and services ensures that your brand maintains its value while fostering a fair and competitive retail landscape. Let our team of experts support you in making the right decisions for your brand and help you navigate the complexities of MAP enforcement.

Ron Solomon

Ron Solomon

CEO and Founder, MAPP Trap

Ron Solomon is the CEO and Co-Founder of MAPP Trap, the industry’s leading brand protection platform. A recognized subject matter expert in eCommerce enforcement, Ron draws from his firsthand experience as an entrepreneur to help manufacturers combat unauthorized sellers and safeguard their brand equity. 

In 2012, flowing from the needs of his own award-winning toy and book company, Swingset Press, Ron launched MAPP Trap to solve the challenges of uncontrolled eCommerce and intellectual property erosion. Today, the platform is a standard for market integrity, trusted by brands across the pet, gift, nutrition, beauty, and sporting goods industries. 

Guides & Tips

4 Benefits of Moving MAP Monitoring to the Top of Your To-Do List

Why Serious Brands Monitor e-Commerce (Even When They’re Not Ready to Enforce)

Finding an Authorized Online Retailer

CHAT WITH US

GET A FREE ECOMMERCE ASSESSMENT REPORT